Request Your Free Consultation

Our team is standing by to help. Call us at (800) 561-4887 or complete this form to schedule a free consultation with us.

Submitting this form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Click for Your FREE Case Review Click for Your FREE Case Review

Company Slaps $3,500 Fine on Customer for Negative Online Review

By Brian Chase on November 20, 2013 - No comments

Before we make a purchase online or signing up for something online, most of us hit the “I agree” button in a hurry. We all know we’re supposed to read the Terms and Conditions before we hit that button. But, really, who does? The website, which bills itself as the seller of “office toys for geeks,” slipped in a clause in its agreement telling buyers that those who post negative comments online about them will be fined $3,500.

 Bullied into Submission talks about the story of customer, Jen Palmer, who ordered merchandise from the company. But she never actually received the package she ordered and Paypal automatically cancelled the transaction after a month. But when she couldn’t get in touch with the company, Palmer vented her frustrations by posting a negative comment about at Palmer was shocked to get a notice from Kleargear three years after she posted the negative review. The notice demanded that she delete that negative comment or pay $3,500 for “legal fees and court costs.” They even threatened to go to a third-party collection firm if she didn’t pay the money in 30 calendar days.

As it turned out refused to delete Palmer’s comment and told her that she would have to pay them $2,000 to do so. When the Palmers were unable to pay either site, Kleargear dinged their credit making it hard for them to even apply for much-needed loans. Their story was made public by a local CBS affiliate in Utah this week. Strangely enough, the offending clauses appear to have been dropped from Kleargear’s website entirely.

What Does the Law Say?

Under California Civil Code section 1670.5, the enforcement of such a term in a contract such as this one can be defeated as an “unconscionable clause.” This law is most often applied to terms that are buried in the middle of the contract – terms that have no relevance to the central purpose of the contract. However, such contracts have become a part of our daily lives. We enter into these contracts for a variety of purposes from online shopping to renting a house.

In this case, the Palmers may also argue that the contract’s clause attempted to restrict them from expressing their opinion. This, in legal terms, is known as “prior restraint’, which is illegal when it comes to disputes, let alone a contracting party imposing the restraint on the right of the other person to speak.

The other issue in the case of the Palmers is the manner in which the company tried to extract a fine for the alleged breach of contract. The law requires that any such amount set must represent the result of a “reasonable endeavor” by the parties to estimate a FAIR, average compensation for any loss that may be sustained. However, in this case, the penalty for posting a negative review was not negotiated between the parties. It is also nearly impossible to estimate an across-the-board damage amount that such a company may suffer from a negative online review.

The Financial Damage

There is no question that these types of actions on the part of companies and corporations can have serious emotional and financial impacts on consumers. In this case, a company took the law into its hands, in the most outrageous manner. The consumer’s credit report was damaged, which meant that they could not apply for a home loan, car loan or even store credit. A ding on your credit doesn’t go away for many years, which is certainly a long-term impact on the consumer – not to mention the stress it causes. In such cases, it may be well worth your time to schedule a free consultation with a consumer rights attorney to explore your options.


Posted in: Personal Injury

About the Author: Brian Chase

Leave a Reply:

Was This Page Helpful? Yes | No

Daily Journal Top Lawyer 2020
See All Ratings And Awards

Have a question that wasn't answered here?

Call Us!

(800) 561-4887

Fill Out Our

Contact Form