En Español

Defective Automobile Seatback Video

Attorney Brian Chase of Bisnar Chase Personal Injury Attorneys Discusses the Dangers of Defective Car Seats on FOX 11 News Los Angeles

Video Transcription

When you are in a car crash, you are protected by seatbelts and airbags in the front and more air bags on the side. But what happens when you are rear ended and get thrown backwards? Phil Shoeman reports on a deadly gap in safety regulations as Fox Eleven investigates dangerous and defective car seats.

Many of the drivers never saw what hit them. A rear end collision the car seat breaks. The impact is devastating.

"I actually thought she was dead."

"I would probably never walk again."

"They told me not to expect her to make it through the night."

Critics say weak regulations mean most car seats are so flimsy they can be death traps in rear end crashes, even at slow speeds.

"My eight year old daughter shouldn't be dead in a fender bender."

Many safety experts say that beneath the plush padding of most car seats is a metal frame that is little more than a glorified aluminum beach chair. They say the seat that's supposed to have your back often doesn't.

"I was just waiting at a stoplight."

Jacqueline Romine was taking her boyfriend home from work when a pickup rear ended them. The pickup driver was thrown forward into the seatbelt and airbag, but the rear end collision had thrown Jacqueline backward.

"I felt like I was going backward in slow motion."

Her protection the car's seat collapsed hurling her headfirst into the back.

"She just immediately broke out into tears saying she couldn't feel her legs."

Paramedics rushed her to the hospital where doctors found she had broken her neck in four places.

"The bone was completely crushed."

She's now a paraplegic in a wheelchair.

"I'm paralyzed from the chest down."

Romine's attorney Brian Chase specializes in auto defects lawsuits. He's still working her case. He says she's paralyzed because of a widespread problem.

"I would say 95+% of all vehicles on the road, which is tens of millions, all have this defect in it.

He says this defect is the weakness of the frames and gears in the car seats even when they meet the government standards.

"The problem is that we have a watered down safety standard."

He's talking about National Highway Traffic Safety Administration or NHTSA Regulation 207…long a target of safety consultants like Paul Sheridan.

"Any seat that merely complies with 207 places that occupant at risk. So it is everyone, it's just about everyone."

So the allegation that car seats are just glorified aluminum lawn chairs?

"The flimsy lawn chair would get through the federal regulations as they are currently written."

Sheridan says that means even low speed crashes can be fatal.

"A 15 MPH rear impact will collapse most of the seats that merely comply with 207."

Stephanie Collins she was out driving with her mother and daughter Crystal.

"My daughter was sitting behind me. "

They were struck from behind at about 30 MPH, Stephanie's seat gave away into Crystal.

"She was making a gurgling sound, it wasn't right."

Crystal died at the hospital.

"That's the actual car. You can see both defective car seats are laid down."

Chase reconstructed that accident in a crash test like this one.

"Stephanie Collin's head went back and struck her 9 year old daughter in the chest and ruptured her aorta."

Damage to vehicles was minor. Sheraton says that government's own tests clearly demonstrate the problems and have for years.

Sheratons says the answer is simple, require stronger seats already common in cars like Mercedes and a few American Cars like the Chrysler Sea Bring. The cost to fix it?

"I would estimate anywhere $5 - $6 and we have a safe front seat."

Nobody has been tracking just how many deaths and injuries have been caused by defective car seats. But the relatively low cost to fix these enrages those who have already paid such a huge price. They are calling for change.

"They could have done something about this before it killed my child."

Phil Shoeman for Fox 11 News.

Poor Mother. Well, The National Highway Safety Administration didn't respond to our request for comment. Congress is holding hearings this week on major reforms to regulators in the wake of the Toyota recall.

For questions or to discuss your case, please call 949-203-3814.

Have a question that wasn't answered here?

(800) 561-4887

Was This Page Helpful? Yes | No

Client Reviews of Bisnar Chase

“I am very pleased with the results this law firm obtained for me. Their professionalism, attentiveness and friendliness was outstanding. They listened to me, answered my questions, advised me and kept me informed. A truck hit my car causing me serious injuries, medical bills, lost time from work and damaged to my car. They took care of everything wonderfully. They helped with getting my car repaired and a rental car. They helped me get medical help. They got my doctor bills paid, kept me from having to go to court and obtained a settlement for me beyond my expectations. Four of my family members have used these guys and had equally good experiences. One of my relatives consulted with them and got great advise about handling her matter. Mr. Bisnar told her she didn't need an attorney and told her how to handle it. She couldn't believe the compassion and great advise, especially without a fee. Mr. Bisnar helped my brother-in-law get a multiple six-figure recovery in an employment law dispute. Starting with the receptionist, my paralegal, the paralegal supervisor, Mrs. De La Torre, Mrs. Barker and Mr. Bisnar himself, everyone was helpful, friendly and professional. It was a refreshing experience after a bad accident. They send me a birthday card with a Baskin Robins gift certificate every year. In January they send me chocolate dipped fortune cookies. They have even offered me Lakers' tickets. They certainly didn't forget me after my case was done.”

by Kim E.

reviewed at Yelp

“I did a car accident case with these guys. They were quick, efficient and friendly. Ended up with a great settlement. Why did I get the royal treatment? No idea.”

by Jacob C.

reviewed at Yelp

“We received an email from A.G. Edwards stating they have received the settlement check from Nissan. Once again, I cannot begin to articulate our gratitude to the Bisnar Chase staff - we are so very thankful for all you have done for Josh. As parents, Charlotte and I can rest in peace, when that day comes, knowing that Josh's needs have been taken care of, and his financial future is in good hands with sound financial planners at A.G. Edwards. On December 17, 2003 we received a call from the paramedics stating that Josh and Lisa had been in a severe accident, and we needed to meet them at the emergency room. I remember telling God that I can deal with missing limbs because they can be replaced, but please do not take him from us. A month later we met with members of your staff for the first time, Josh had a traumatic brain injury and his future was looking pretty bleak; we had no idea where he would be eighteen months later. All we could think of at the time was that our son's future, his goals, and dreams had been taken from him so abruptly. As time passed, Josh continued to improve and he began his journey of recovery. Many have been involved in this process, and you and your staff have been an integral part of Josh's recovery, and we will be forever grateful. God has brought so many people into our lives, and we are so very blessed. Numerous emails were sent to Personal Injury Attorney's. John...you were on a ski trip at Big Bear with your family, and you were the only Personal Injury Attorney to respond - I believe this was divine intervention. Josh has a professor from Mt. San Jacinto College who has taken him "under his wing," and is showing him other career possibilities. John, the future looks good for Josh - thank you!”

by K N.

reviewed at Yelp

See All Ratings And Awards

The BISNAR CHASE Difference

  • “I was in a serious auto accident when I was in law school. I had to hire a personal injury attorney and had a really bad experience.”

    John Bisnar

    on what made him want to become a personal injury attorney

  • “If you hire Bisnar | Chase and we don't recover money for you in your case, you owe us absolutely nothing.”

    Brian Chase

    on whether or not you would owe money if your case was lost

  • “Whatever the philosphy of the management is, is going to be carried through by the employees and it’s going to reflect on the experience the clients have.”

    John Bisnar

    on his philosophy on running a law firm

  • “The insurance companies are going to be investigating that accident the day it happens. You need to have a lawyer on your side the day it happens as well.”

    Brian Chase

    on when you should contact an attorney

  • “The first thing we want to do with our clients is to relieve the stress. Make them feel comfortable. Treat them as an honored guest.”

    John Bisnar

    on how he would define superior client representation

  • “It's hard to answer that question right up front without a thorough analysis. What I can guarantee you is, with the resources of Bisnar | Chase we will maximize the value of your case.”

    Brian Chase

    on what your case is worth

Bisnar Chase Personal Injury Attorneys
1301 Dove St #120
Newport Beach, CA 92660

local: (949) 203-3814
Get Directions

California Personal Injury Blog