En EspaƱol

California Supreme Court Says "No" To ER "Balance Billing"

Personal injury lawyers have seen disputes between HMOs and ER physicians for years. In a victory for patients, the California Supreme Court has decided that ER physicians may not go after patients for any outstanding balance remaining after being paid for their emergency services by the patient's HMO.

Prior to the court's decision, ER physicians had been going around HMOs and seeking payment from patients who were often surprised by an additional bill for their services. "This is a clear victory for ER patients," noted California personal injury attorney John Bisnar. "Patients who made good faith premium payments to HMOs had a reasonable expectation that the HMO would pay for their ER expenses, less any deductibles.

State law mandates that ER physicians perform emergency services to stabilize a patient. If the patient is a member of an HMO, the HMO is statutorily required to pay for the emergency care. The problem, in many cases, is that in ER situations, HMOs may not have had a prior contract with the physician performing the service. And thus, the increasing source of friction has been the widening gap between what the HMO will pay and what ER physicians will accept. This has forced many ER physicians to seek full compensation for their services, billing patients directly for the balance, and in some cases, even hiring collection agencies to hound patients. The court's decision finally puts an end to these practices.

In its opinion, the court said, "We conclude that billing disputes over Emergency medical care must be resolved solely between the emergency room Doctors, who are entitled to a reasonable payment for their services, and the HMO, Which is obligated to make that payment? A patient who is a member of an HMO May not be injected into the dispute. Emergency room doctors may not bill the Patient for the disputed amount."

"This decision gives ER doctors a refuge against unfair determinations by HMOs who have been offering doctors increasingly lower reimbursements for their services," observed John Bisnar. "The legislature has a history of siding with the patients and avoiding the insertion of patients in these disputes."

In 1975, the Legislature banned balance billing when an HMO is contractually obligated to pay the bill. Since 1994, HMO's have been obligated to pay for emergency care and that the Knox-Keene Act permits emergency room doctors to sue HMO's directly over billing disputes. These provisions strongly suggest that doctors may not bill patients directly when a dispute arises between doctors and the HMO's. Other provisions point in the same direction, requiring emergency room doctors to render emergency care without questioning a patient's ability to pay. Such provisions call for the patient or their legally responsible relative or guardian to execute an agreement to pay for services rendered or supply insurance or credit information promptly after the services are rendered. This implies that once patients who are members of an HMO provide insurance information, they have satisfied their obligation towards the doctors. The legislative intent was to ensure the best possible health care for the public at the lowest possible cost by transferring the financial risk of health care from patients to providers.

The Legislature further contemplated there may be disputes over the amounts owed to non-contracting providers such as emergency room doctors, and therefore the Knox-Keene Act requires that each HMO "shall ensure that a dispute resolution mechanism is accessible to non-contracting providers for the purpose of resolving billing and claims disputes."

"The goal here was to ensure that each HMO adopts a dispute resolution mechanism that is "fair, fast, and cost-effective for contracting and non-contracting providers,"" noted John Bisnar. "The legislature acted to protect the interests of non-contracting providers in reimbursement disputes by prohibiting HMO's from engaging in unfair payment patterns, unjust payment reductions, claim denials, and other unfair practices."

While the bill an ER doctor submits may or may not be the reasonable payment to which they are entitled, an HMO does not have limitless discretion to determine unilaterally the amount it will reimburse a non-contracting provider. Conversely, emergency room doctors do not have unfettered discretion to charge whatever they choose for emergency services. Emergency room doctors and HMO's must resolve their disputes among themselves.

If you or a loved one has suffered serious injuries as the result of a defective auto part or vehicle, contact the experienced California auto products liability attorneys at Bisnar | Chase Personal Injury Attorneys, LLP for a free consultation. We will use our extensive knowledge and resources to achieve the best possible results for you and your family.


Share this:

See All Ratings And Awards

The BISNAR | CHASE Difference

  • “I was in a serious auto accident when I was in law school. I had to hire a personal injury attorney and had a really bad experience.”

    John Bisnar

    on what made him want to become a personal injury attorney

  • “I went to law school knowing I wanted to be a personal injury attorney. I wanted my life’s work to have a positive impact on other people’s lives.”

    Brian Chase

    on what made him want to become a personal injury attorney

  • “Whatever the philosphy of the management is, is going to be carried through by the employees and it’s going to reflect on the experience the clients have.”

    John Bisnar

    on his philosophy on running a law firm

  • “Everybody either drives in a car or rides in a car, so when I do the auto defect cases I really feel like I’m making the world safer by making vehicles safer.”

    Brian Chase

    on why he focuses on auto defect cases

  • “The first thing we want to do with our clients is to relieve the stress. Make them feel comfortable. Treat them as an honored guest.”

    John Bisnar

    on how he would define superior client representation

  • “Corporate greed is a reality in our world and I see it time and time again. Especially, with the auto defect cases we focus on.”

    Brian Chase

    on corporate greed and how it affects the consumer

  • “You are dealing with people who are seriously injured or have lost a family member...Compassion is understanding someone else’s situation.”

    John Bisnar

    on the role compassion plays in his profession

  • “There are many, many defects in vehicles that can lead to life or death that could be fixed with a mere $40-$50 [on the assembly line].”

    Brian Chase

    on the shocking facts about the vehicles we drive

  • “...if [manufacturers] build a dangerous product and someone is seriously injured from that, some personal inury lawyer is going to call them on the carpet about it.”

    John Bisnar

    on how Bisnar | Chase has helped make the world a better place

  • “I’m convinced, because of all the lawsuits...the auto industry finally found out it was cheaper to fix the problem than to keep paying in the litigation.”

    Brian Chase

    on making the world a safer place

  • “I bring in the best employees that I can and I want them to have a workplace that is condusive to them doing their best work.”

    John Bisnar

    on the work environment created at Bisnar | Chase

  • “When you have a client come in that’s in a wheelchair...or you meet a wife who has lost their husband or they’ve lost their child, it’s diffucult not to get emotionally involved.”

    Brian Chase

    on the biggest challenges he faces as a personal injury lawyer

  • “...it is part of our civic responsibility and it is our great fortune to be in a position to be able to help support our community...”

    John Bisnar

    on the importance of giving back to the community

  • “My motivation of going to law school to have my life’s work help other people...when I see that come to fruition, I’m very pleased and very happy with that.”

    Brian Chase

    on the accomplishments he is most proud of

  • “Seeing the growth of my employees, seeing them mature professionally, personally, and grow into the great professionals they have become is tremendous.”

    John Bisnar

    on the greatest satisfaction derived from his work

  • “I was always jealous of doctors. They get to save lives and they get to heal. I don’t get to do that but I get to have a very big impact on another person’s life...”

    Brian Chase

    on the greatest satisfaction derived from his work

  • “There’s going to people that you meet, that you can mentor...You can make a difference in their lives, you can make a difference in their client’s lives.”

    John Bisnar

    on mentoring young attorneys

  • “I’m the president-elect this year and I’ll be the president next year of the Consumer Advocate Attorneys of California and I find that to be a rewarding thing...”

    Brian Chase

    on being an advocate for the people of California

  • “The Lakers have always been a winning organization, a class organization. I’ve used the Lakers as kind of a model for how to run my practice as well.”

    John Bisnar

    on his passions in life

  • “We try to figure out how we can help [our clients] get through what they’re going through emotionally. Because just getting them compensated is only part of the job.”

    Brian Chase

    on the role compassion plays in his profession

Bisnar | Chase • 1301 Dove St #120
Newport Beach, CA 92660
local: (949) 203-3814
Get Directions

California Personal Injury Blog

Chrysler Recalls Cars And SUVs For Fire Hazard

Nearly a million Chrysler, Dodge, and Jeep vehicles are being recalled for potential fire hazards. Several makes and models are included in the recalls.

read article

Why Do Federal Regulators Allow Regional Car Recalls?

A couple of U.S. senators are asking why car manufacturers are able to issue regional vehicle recalls without regards to vehicles outside of those regions.

read article

Toyota Recalls Vehicles For Potential Fuel Leaks and Fire Danger

Toyota is recalling nearly 1.7 million vehicles worldwide due to an issue that could lead to possible fuel leaks and a fire hazard.

read article

Connect

Copyright & Disclaimer

Disclaimer: The legal information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice, nor the formation of an attorney-client relationship. Any results set forth here were dependent on the facts of that case and the results will differ from case to case.

Bisnar | Chase serves all of California. In addition, we represent clients in other states through our associations with local law firms. Through the local firm, we will be admitted to practice law in their state, pro hac vice, meaning "for this particular occasion." When in our client's interest, we employ the local law firm (at no additional cost to our client) to assist us with routine court appearances and discovery proceedings to more efficiently pursue our client's cause.

Copyright © 1999- Bisnar | Chase Personal Injury Attorneys, LLP - All rights reserved. Location: 1301 Dove St. #120, Newport Beach, CA 92660 Tel: 949-203-3814

SLS Consulting