En Español

Do I have a case for my car accident?

Free Case Evaluation - Our full time staff is ready to evaluate your case submission and will respond in a timely manner.

If Your Car Gets Towed

The following information is provided for your information only.

Please do not contact us regarding illegal towing unless serious personal injuries are involved.

We no longer handle illegal towing cases.

Most people react to their car getting towed by getting angry, upset, and then paying to get their car out of lock up. Few people take the time to truly fight their case, usually because the cost of an attorney makes the debacle cost more than it is worth. In Westervelt vs. Beach Cities Towing Services, Inc. (BCTS), the plaintiff takes the case on himself and makes a compelling argument for why BCTS had no right to tow his vehicle, and that he should be paid the towing and storage fees, court costs, and punitive damages as compensation for the ordeal.

Towing Incident

The plaintiff states that on 10/21/2010 his car was illegally towed from a space behind his garage in Rancho Santa Margarita. No warning or notice was given that this was being done; plaintiff states that the driver clearly made an independent decision to tow his vehicle without a PPI (Private Party Impound) or a fire lane sign being present at the location.

Plaintiff's Arguments

Defendant's report states that this towing occurred as a result of a general order to tow from MGMT, with no agent of the property owner present at the time of the tow. No name or phone number of such person being present was shown on the report made by Defendant, nor did anyone call to complain about plaintiff's car being parked behind his garage. Plaintiff further states that defendant's report falsely states that his car was parked in a fire lane. Plaintiff states that there is no fire lane sign or a painted curb as required by statue to mark a designated fire lane.

Plaintiff argues that BCTS is relying on an agreement with the former Sonoma Court Management Board of Directors made in and about the year 2004. That agreement pre-dates the predatory towing revisions to CVC 22658. The new statutory towing provisions of the revised CVC22658 makes illegal any attempt to delegate general authority to tow to BCTS, or anyone else.

Plaintiff is asking for actual damages in the sum of $200.00 in towing and storage fees, $60.00 in court costs, and punitive damages in the sum of $800.00 or four times the amount of tow charges for a total relief in the sum of $1,060.00.

Governing Statutory Authority

CVC Article 22658 states that a towing company shall not remove or commence the removal of a vehicle from private property without first obtaining written authorization from the property owner or lessee, or an employee or agent thereof, who shall be present at the time of removal. General authorization to remove or commence removal of a vehicle at the towing company's discretion shall not be delegated to a towing company or its affiliates except in the case of a vehicle unlawfully parked within 15 feet of a fire hydrant or in a fire lane, or in a manner that interferes with any entrance to, or exit from, the private property.


Whether this man will be successful in his plight is unpredictable, but his willingness to go the distance to obtain fair compensation for his losses is admirable. An inefficient towing system wastes law enforcement resources and frustrates citizens. The increasing number of holes in the system is allowing room for towing and storage companies to take advantage of the system. Even if he loses his case, the defendant may think twice before towing a vehicle under the same circumstances in the future. When we challenge companies to uphold the law, we contribute to decreasing future violations.

Help for Victims of Catastrophic Injury Accidents

If you have been seriously injured in a catastrophic injury accident, call Bisnar Chase Personal Injury Attorneys at 949-203-3814. Our Los Angeles personal injury attorneys have helped a number of injured accident victims recover fair compensation for their personal injury claim. You will experience award winning representation and outstanding personal service by a friendly law firm in a comfortable environment.

Was This Page Helpful? Yes | No

Auto Accident Attorneys

  • If you or a loved one have suffered in a car accident as a result of someone else’s negligence, know your rights and contact an attorney today.
  • Serving California since 1978.
  • Recovered over $250M in verdicts and settlements
  • Rated top attorneys year after year.
  • No recovery, no fee promise.

Client Reviews of Bisnar Chase

“I don’t even know where to start, because I really wanted to write this recommendation even if there was no star or rating to be given! My daughter and I were in a bad car accident in 2011. She received a broke jaw, broken pelvic, broken arm, and a ruptured ear drum. I prayed to the lord while I was in ICU to guide me and send me to the right attorney that would help me and my daughter and not just look at us as a monetary opportunity. After much research I choose Bisnar Chase.
After spending 2 months in the ICU, we were in a long recovery process. Learning to walk, to eat due to wire shut for months! Back to the basic all over again… 4 years later it just came to an end! I tell you I have 2 different paralegals assisting me but Colleen Cadogan was the best I had this past year… This lady, emailed me, called me, send me words of encouragement almost every week! When I least expect it and I had a horrible day or had many questions and concerns she was there! As the paralegal doing her job, but also as a human being, a mother, a wife….just genuinely concern for my daughter and I. As the case came to a close….I will always remember the team of professionals and I would recommended Bisnar Chase to anyone….and be patient, patience”

by Maria Vasquez

reviewed at Google+

“Bisnar Chase is an outstanding firm. After working with them for several years, I have been consistently impressed by their expertise and willingness to help. I highly recommend this firm.”

by Maddy King

reviewed at Google+

“I knew Bisnar Chase would help me. Your law firm is excellent and makes me wish I could work there!”

by Cynthia

reviewed at Super Pages


Watch Video

Are the Insurance Companies on My Side?

Watch Video

Can My Lawyer Help Me Get My Car Repaired?