En Español

Auto Defect Case Press Releases

California Auto Defects Lawyers Win Appeal in Case Against Ford Motor Company

Los Angeles, CA (Vocus) June 24, 2010

The California auto defects lawyers of BISNAR CHASE (www.BestAttorney.com)] today announced they have won an appeal from the Superior Court of Los Angeles County in an auto defects case involving Ford Motor Company, Cooper Tire and Rubber Company, Leader Auto Sales of San Diego, California, and Power Tires, also of San Diego. The original case, filed in 2006 in San Diego County Superior Court, involves a 1995 Ford Explorer rollover accident that killed two occupants and seriously injured two others after the vehicle's tire lost its tread and came apart, causing the SUV to lose control and roll over. The appeal was granted on May 27, 2010 and the opinion has been certified for publication (case # JCCP-4292/GIC873813).

Ford Explorer Rollover Crash Kills Two, Seriously Injures Two Others

According to the lawsuit, in February 2006, four properly restrained occupants of a 1995 Ford Explorer were traveling in Mexico, towards Churintzio, Michoacan, on the Mexico City-Nogales Highway, in the state of Michoacan. The vehicle was traveling at highway speeds when the right rear tire lost its tread and came apart, causing the SUV to lose control and rollover. When it veered off the paved surface of the road and rolled over into the center dividing space, its roof crushed inward, severely injuring two occupants and killing two others.    

The lawsuit claims the 1995 Ford Explorer was wrought with a variety of defects, including unsafe tires that were prone to tread separation, defective A and B pillars/windshield headers and roof rails that lacked sufficient strength and structural integrity to withstand roof crushing forces. In addition, the lawsuit alleges the vehicle had insufficient directional and lateral roll stability, defective seat belts, car seat defects, and faulty window systems that allowed occupants to be ejected and lacerated during the rollover accident sequence.

The lawsuit was brought against the defendants by Jose Mazon Martinez and Jesus Manuel Ibarra Campos, survivors of the crash, and family members of Georgina Isabel Ibarra Campos De Esparza and Andres Esparza Hernandez. Both sustained fatal injuries in the vehicle crash resulting in wrongful death claims.

Ford Lawsuit Dismissed in California, BISNAR CHASE Appeals

In February 2007, the defendants moved to have their case dismissed in California and relocated to Mexico, arguing the crash occurred in Mexico and involved residents who lived there, making Mexico the most appropriate forum in which to try the case. The motion to dismiss the case in California — also known as "forum non conveniens" (or "inappropriate forum") -- was granted by the trial court and the case was subsequently dismissed in California.

On appeal, BISNAR CHASE argued the defendants took advantage of California discovery laws to delay their motion to dismiss by obtaining information that went far beyond the issues of whether California or Mexico was an appropriate forum to try the case and actually sought information that would not have been discoverable under Mexican law. What's more, court documents reveal much of the information requested by the defendants was irrelevant in determining whether or not the case should be dismissed in California and moved to Mexico, which delayed the judicial process even further.

"It was clear the defendants used discovery laws here in California to delay their motion to dismiss," said Brian Chase, senior partner at BISNAR CHASE Los Angeles Personal Injury Lawyers. "What's more, much of the information they requested from our clients had absolutely nothing to do with determining the most appropriate forum in which to try the case."

On May 27, 2010, the appellate court reversed the trial court's decision, denying the defendants' motion to dismiss. The plaintiffs were awarded their court costs on appeal and further proceedings have been ordered in this case.

"The appellate court made the right decision here," said Chase. "This is a classic example of the defendants wanting their cake and eating it too. They can't take advantage of California law for their benefit, and then argue the California legal system is an inappropriate forum. I'm glad the court of appeal agreed."


Top-rated BISNAR CHASE Personal Injury Attorneys have won hundreds of millions of dollars for over 10,000 clients who have been very seriously injured or lost a family member due to an accident, defective product or negligence throughout California. The law firm has won a wide variety of auto defect cases against most of the major auto manufacturers, including Ford, General Motors, Toyota, Nissan and Chrysler. Get a complimentary copy of Still Unsafe at Any Speed: Auto Defects that Cause Wrongful Deaths and Catastrophic Injuries. For more information, visit www.AutoProductliabilityLawyers.com and www.ProductDefectNewsandAdviceBlog.com.

Have a question that wasn't answered here?

(800) 561-4887

Was This Page Helpful? Yes | No

Client Reviews of Bisnar Chase

“I don’t even know where to start, because I really wanted to write this recommendation even if there was no star or rating to be given! My daughter and I were in a bad car accident in 2011. She received a broke jaw, broken pelvic, broken arm, and a ruptured ear drum. I prayed to the lord while I was in ICU to guide me and send me to the right attorney that would help me and my daughter and not just look at us as a monetary opportunity. After much research I choose Bisnar Chase.
After spending 2 months in the ICU, we were in a long recovery process. Learning to walk, to eat due to wire shut for months! Back to the basic all over again… 4 years later it just came to an end! I tell you I have 2 different paralegals assisting me but Colleen Cadogan was the best I had this past year… This lady, emailed me, called me, send me words of encouragement almost every week! When I least expect it and I had a horrible day or had many questions and concerns she was there! As the paralegal doing her job, but also as a human being, a mother, a wife….just genuinely concern for my daughter and I. As the case came to a close….I will always remember the team of professionals and I would recommended Bisnar Chase to anyone….and be patient, patience”

by Maria Vasquez

reviewed at Google+

“I put up something about these guys before, but its gone now... I had a really good experience with this firm. I didn't have a huge case, but they still called me on a regular basis and wrapped things up pretty quickly after I finished treating. I had a really good experience with this firm.”

by John P.

reviewed at Yelp

“I could not recommend Bisnar & Chase highly enough! Now, I must be forthcoming and tell you that I am writing this review on behalf of my wonderful mother. You see, she's a mom, and therefor [sic] by nature is completely unable to do even the most simple of tasks on the internet. Like writing a a Yelp review. But we all love our moms don't we? Yes. We all love our moms (except Charles Manson), and would do anything to make sure they are protected and well taken care of. Upon referral from my mother's coworker, we contacted Bisnar & Chase. They had done a great job in this previous case and were located extremely close to both UCI and home, which made stopping by their office very convenient for my Mom. My Mom had been in an auto accident, nothing crazy but not a mere fender bender, and suffered what we thought to be some minor whiplash. Months later this was definitely not the case. Her client experience with the associates at Bisnar & Chase was so impressive that she raved to me about every time she heard anything from them. How thorough they were. How they listened better than I did (or something to that effect). How she liked Shannon and Mr. Bisnar and felt that they really had her best interests at heart. I honestly couldn't get her to shut up about them. But as a daughter that last part was all that I needed to hear to know that I we had found the right people and I could sleep easy at night knowing my Mom was in good hands. The Bisnar & Chase team really went above and beyond my family's expectations. And for that I am extremely grateful. If you live in the Newport Beach/Irvine/Costa Mesa/General Orange County area I would highly recommend Bisnar & Chase to both friends, and family.”

by Chelsea C.

reviewed at Yelp

See All Ratings And Awards

The BISNAR CHASE Difference

  • “I was in a serious auto accident when I was in law school. I had to hire a personal injury attorney and had a really bad experience.”

    John Bisnar

    on what made him want to become a personal injury attorney

  • “If you hire Bisnar | Chase and we don't recover money for you in your case, you owe us absolutely nothing.”

    Brian Chase

    on whether or not you would owe money if your case was lost

  • “Whatever the philosphy of the management is, is going to be carried through by the employees and it’s going to reflect on the experience the clients have.”

    John Bisnar

    on his philosophy on running a law firm

  • “The insurance companies are going to be investigating that accident the day it happens. You need to have a lawyer on your side the day it happens as well.”

    Brian Chase

    on when you should contact an attorney

  • “The first thing we want to do with our clients is to relieve the stress. Make them feel comfortable. Treat them as an honored guest.”

    John Bisnar

    on how he would define superior client representation

  • “It's hard to answer that question right up front without a thorough analysis. What I can guarantee you is, with the resources of Bisnar | Chase we will maximize the value of your case.”

    Brian Chase

    on what your case is worth

Bisnar Chase Personal Injury Attorneys
1301 Dove St #120
Newport Beach, CA 92660

local: (949) 203-3814
Get Directions

California Personal Injury Blog